Friend or foe: assessing the value of animal models for facilitating clinical breakthroughs in complement research

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Animal experiments have long been a cornerstone of advancements in biomedical research, particularly in developing novel therapeutic strategies for inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. However, these historically important approaches are now facing growing scrutiny for ethical reasons, concerns about translational limitations to human biology, and the rising availability of animal-free research methods. This shift raises a critical question: How relevant and effective are animal models for driving future advancements in today’s research landscape? This Review aims to explore this question within the field of biomedical research on the complement system, critically evaluating the contribution of animal models to the recent advancements and clinical successes of complement-targeted therapies. Specifically, we assess areas where animal studies have been indispensable for elucidating disease mechanisms and conducting preclinical evaluations, alongside instances where findings from animal models failed to translate successfully to human trials. Furthermore, we discuss similarities and differences in the complement system between animals and humans and explore innovations in animal research designed to improve translatability to human biology. By assessing the contributions of animal studies to complement therapeutics, this Review aims to provide insights into animal models’ strengths, limitations, and evolving role in complement research.

Authors

Felix Poppelaars, V. Michael Holers, Joshua M. Thurman

Role of local complement activation in kidney fibrosis and repair

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

The complement system is an important component of the innate immune system involved in host defense and maintaining homeostasis. While the liver is the main source of complement proteins in the bloodstream, recent research has shown that various tissues, including the kidneys, can produce complement components locally in response to both acute and chronic inflammation. This Review highlights evidence from animal models of glomerular and tubulointerstitial kidney disease showing increased expression of intracellular complement in the kidneys. Studies using knockout mice for complement and complement receptors, along with complement inhibitors, have demonstrated that reduced complement activation in animal models of kidney fibrosis led to reduced inflammation and fibrosis, thereby supporting the pathogenic role of complement activation. Data from single-cell RNA-sequencing, spatial transcriptomics, and proteomics studies further demonstrate that alterations in local complement levels contribute to the fibrotic microenvironment observed in these models. Additionally, kidney biopsy results from patients with acute kidney injury and chronic kidney disease (CKD) indicate an increased expression of intracellular complement components as disease progresses. Developing drugs aimed at diminishing the expression and activation of local complement in glomerular and tubulointerstitial kidney disease could provide a novel approach to managing CKD.

Authors

Didier Portilla, Vikram Sabapathy, Daniel Chauss

The secret life of complement: challenges and opportunities in exploring functions of the complosome in disease

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

The complement system is a highly conserved and essential immune component with pivotal roles in innate and adaptive immunity. It is increasingly recognized that the complement system has a profound impact on disease. Current complement-targeting therapeutics for clinical use almost exclusively target the complement system in circulation. However, recent discoveries have demonstrated that complement is not only liver derived and plasma operative, but also synthesized and activated inside many cells locally within tissues, performing noncanonical, cell-autonomous intracellular functions, collectively referred to as the complosome. These intracellular complement pathways are distinct from the classical plasma-based system and critical for regulating fundamental cellular processes, including metabolism, gene transcription, autophagy, and the activation and resolution of inflammation. This Review explores the emerging roles of the complosome and current knowledge regarding its relation to human diseases, highlighting evidence across organ systems and disease states, including the kidneys, digestive tract, lungs, heart, CNS, musculoskeletal system, skin, and cancer. We also review current scientific approaches for detecting and functionally investigating the complosome, addressing challenges such as technological limitations and the need for advanced experimental models to delineate its tissue-specific roles. Finally, we discuss central unanswered questions critical for developing innovative therapeutic strategies targeting intracellular complement pathways. These strategies hold potential to modulate disease-specific mechanisms while preserving systemic complement activity.

Authors

Tilo Freiwald, Behdad Afzali

Social, microbial, and immune factors linking bacterial vaginosis and infectious diseases

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Bacterial vaginosis (BV) is a polymicrobial condition of the vaginal microbiota associated with a variety of sexually transmitted infections, infections of maternal and fetal tissues during pregnancy, and even some infections outside of the reproductive tract, including the urinary tract and mouth. BV has also been associated with conditions in which the body generates prominent inflammatory reactions to microbes, including infections of the cervix and other upper genital tract tissues. For reasons still not understood, BV is a highly recurrent and often difficult-to-treat condition, complicating attempts to prevent these associated infections. An additional layer of complexity arises from the increasing awareness that the presence of BV-associated bacteria in the vagina is not always symptomatic or associated with adverse outcomes. In this concise Review, we summarize and synthesize three groups of factors grounded in the literature that may be fueling the associations between BV and infection: (a) aspects of society and culture; (b) pathogens, virulence factors, and processes of microbial antagonism and synergy; and (c) host factors, such as genetics and immunity. Our goal is to understand what contexts and combinations of microbial, host, and social factors conspire to make BV virulent in some individuals but not others. Disrupting these patterns more systematically may achieve healthier outcomes.

Authors

Nicole M. Gilbert, Luis A. Ramirez Hernandez, Daniela Berman, Sydney Morrill, Pascal Gagneux, Amanda L. Lewis

Present and future of microbiome-targeting therapeutics

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

A large body of evidence suggests that single- and multiple-strain probiotics and synbiotics could have roles in the management of specific gastrointestinal disorders. However, ongoing concerns regarding the quality and heterogeneity of the clinical data, safety in vulnerable populations, and the lack of regulation of products containing live microbes are barriers to widespread clinical use. Safety and regulatory issues must be addressed and new technologies considered. One alternative future strategy is the use of synthetic bacterial communities, defined as manually assembled consortia of two or more bacteria originally derived from the human gastrointestinal tract. Synthetic bacterial communities can model functional, ecological, and structural aspects of native communities within the gastrointestinal tract, occupying varying nutritional niches and providing the host with a stable, robust, and diverse gut microbiota that can prevent pathobiont colonization by way of colonization resistance. Alternatively, phage therapy is the use of lytic phage to treat bacterial infections. The rise of antimicrobial resistance has led to renewed interest in phage therapy, and the high specificity of phages for their hosts has spurred interest in using phage-based approaches to precisely modulate the microbiome. In this Review, we consider the present and future of microbiome-targeting therapies, with a special focus on early-life applications, such as prevention of necrotizing enterocolitis.

Authors

Lauren E. Lynch, Rachel Lahowetz, Christian Maresso, Austen Terwilliger, Jason Pizzini, Valeria Melendez Hebib, Robert A. Britton, Anthony W. Maresso, Geoffrey A. Preidis

Diet’s impact on gut microbial assemblage in health and disease

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

The gut microbiome has been linked to everything from human behavior to athletic performance to disease pathogenesis. And yet, few universal truths have emerged regarding how the microbiome exerts its effects or responds to the host environment except for one: gut microbiota are exquisitely sensitive to human diets. What we eat from birth onward shapes our gut microbiome composition and function, and this is likely an evolutionarily conserved interaction that benefits the microbe and often the host. However, modern diets and lifestyles have created discordance between our slowly evolving human genome and rapidly adaptable microbiome, and have been implicated in the rise of chronic diseases over the past 75 years. Diet and microbiome interactions have been reviewed extensively, so here we focus on areas of microbiome research that have most illuminated natural and disruptive dietary forces over time in humans, and where we may have opportunities to restore the natural balance of host with microbes in our modern world.

Authors

Carolina Koletic, Amanda Mrad, Anthony Martin, Suzanne Devkota

Metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease and pregnancy

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD) is rising among reproductive-aged individuals and in pregnancy. MASLD in pregnancy does increase such risks as gestational diabetes, preeclampsia, and preterm birth. Although routine screening for MASLD has not been established in pregnancy, individuals with metabolic comorbidities, such as type 2 diabetes mellitus, should be evaluated by liver imaging and liver panel. Preconception counseling should address potential risks as well as need for optimized metabolic health before and during pregnancy. Fibrosis assessment should ideally be completed before pregnancy, to identify cases of cirrhosis that may warrant additional preconception management, such as variceal screening, as well as comanagement with maternal-fetal medicine specialists. In patients with MASLD, aspirin is advised at 12 weeks of gestational age to lower preeclampsia risk. In the absence of cirrhosis, no additional blood test monitoring is needed. In the general population, breastfeeding has beneficial effects on metabolic health in birthing parents and offspring and thus should be encouraged in the setting of MASLD, including access to enhanced lactation support. Research needs include evaluation of the long-term risks of MASLD in pregnancy on metabolic health in birthing parents and infants, as well as safety data for MASLD-directed therapies during pregnancy and lactation.

Authors

Monika Sarkar, Tatyana Kushner

Disease classification, diagnostic challenges, and evolving clinical trial design in MASLD

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD) diagnosis and management have evolved rapidly alongside the increasing prevalence of obesity and related complications. Hepatology has expanded its focus beyond late-stage cirrhosis and portal hypertension to earlier, complex MASLD cases in younger patients, necessitating closer collaboration with endocrinology. The renaming of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) to MASLD reflects its pathophysiology, reduces stigma, and has prompted new research directions. Noninvasive tests such as liver stiffness measurement now play a crucial role in diagnosis, reducing reliance on invasive liver biopsies. However, advanced omics technologies, despite their potential to enhance diagnostic precision and patient stratification, remain underutilized in routine clinical practice. Behavioral factors, including posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and lifestyle choices, influence disease outcomes and must be integrated into patient management strategies. Primary care settings are critical for early screening to prevent progression to advanced disease, yet sizable challenges remain in implementing effective screening protocols. This Review explores these evolving aspects of MASLD diagnosis and management, emphasizing the need for improved diagnostic tools, multidisciplinary collaboration, and holistic care approaches to address existing gaps and ensure comprehensive patient care across all healthcare levels.

Authors

Mette Munk Lauridsen, Kim Ravnskjaer, Lise Lotte Gluud, Arun J. Sanyal

The complement system and kidney cancer: pathogenesis to clinical applications

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Kidney cancer poses unique clinical challenges because of its resistance to conventional treatments and its tendency to metastasize. The kidney is particularly susceptible to dysfunction of the complement system, an immune network that tumors often exploit. Recent discoveries have highlighted that the complement system not only plays a crucial role in immune surveillance and defense in the circulatory system, but also functions intracellularly and autonomously. This concept has shifted the focus of investigation toward understanding how complement proteins influence cancer progression by regulating the tumor microenvironment (TME), cell signaling, proliferation, metabolism, and the immune response. With the complement system and its inhibitors emerging as a promising new class of immunotherapeutics and potential complement-targeted treatments advancing through development pipelines and clinical trials, this Review provides a timely examination of how harnessing the complement system could lead to effective tumor treatments and how to strategically combine complement inhibitors with other cancer treatments, offering renewed hope in the fight against kidney cancer.

Authors

Ravikumar Aalinkeel, Richard J. Quigg, Jessy Alexander

Complement’s involvement in allergic Th2 immunity: a cross-barrier perspective

• Text
• PDF

Abstract

Type 2 (Th2) allergic diseases are chronic conditions characterized by a Th2-polarized immune response to allergens. These diseases can be categorized by affected barrier sites: skin (atopic dermatitis, allergic contact dermatitis), gut (food allergy), and respiratory tract (e.g., asthma, chronic rhinosinusitis). The global prevalence of Th2 allergic diseases has increased the need for a deeper understanding of their pathophysiology. Several associations have been identified between genetic variants in the genes encoding components of the complement system and allergic disease. Moreover, levels of several complement proteins are elevated in patients with allergy. Experimental evidence demonstrates that the complement system plays a critical role in the development of these diseases across barrier sites. While site-specific differences exist in the complement components involved, key pathways, particularly C3 and C5, are prominent across the skin, gut, and lung.

Authors

Sarah A. Thomas, Stephane Lajoie