[HTML][HTML] After further review

LA Turka - The Journal of clinical investigation, 2009 - Am Soc Clin Investig
LA Turka
The Journal of clinical investigation, 2009Am Soc Clin Investig
In the two years that I have been Editor in Chief of the JCI, the editors and I have sent
approximately 2,500 papers for external review. The referee reports that we've received
have spanned the spectrum from incredibly insightful to completely unhelpful. Together with
a longer piece immediately following this editorial, I would like to reflect on what I think
makes a good review.
In the two years that I have been Editor in Chief of the JCI, the editors and I have sent approximately 2,500 papers for external review. The referee reports that we’ve received have spanned the spectrum from incredibly insightful to completely unhelpful. Together with a longer piece immediately following this editorial, I would like to reflect on what I think makes a good review.
The Journal of Clinical Investigation