BRAF inhibitors elicit rapid antitumor responses in the majority of patients with BRAF^V600-mutant melanoma, but acquired drug resistance is almost universal. We sought to identify the core resistance pathways and the extent of tumor heterogeneity during disease progression. We show that mitogen-activated protein kinase reactivation mechanisms were detected among 70% of disease-progressive tissues, with RAS mutations, mutant BRAF amplification, and alternative splicing being most common. We also detected PI3K–PTEN–AKT–upregulating genetic alterations among 22% of progressive melanomas. Distinct molecular lesions in both core drug escape pathways were commonly detected concurrently in the same tumor or among multiple tumors from the same patient. Beyond harboring extensively heterogeneous resistance mechanisms, melanoma regrowth emerging from BRAF inhibitor selection displayed branched evolution marked by altered mutational spectra/signatures and increased fitness. Thus, melanoma genomic heterogeneity contributes significantly to BRAF inhibitor treatment failure, implying upfront, cotargeting of two core pathways as an essential strategy for durable responses.

Significance: This study provides critical insights into how human BRAF-mutant melanoma, a malignancy with marked mutational burden, escapes from BRAF inhibitors. Understanding the core resistance pathways as well as tumor heterogeneity, fitness, and mutational patterns, which emerge under drug selection, lays a foundation to rationalize clinical studies and investigate mechanisms of disease progression. Cancer Discov; 4(1); 80–93. ©2013 AACR.

See related commentary by Solit and Rosen, p. 27

This article is highlighted in the In This Issue feature, p. 1