Hydroxyurea represents an approved treatment for sickle cell anemia and acts as a nitric oxide donor under oxidative conditions in vitro. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy shows that hydroxyurea reacts with oxy-, deoxy-, and methemoglobin to produce 2−6% of iron nitrosyl hemoglobin. No S-nitrosohemoglobin forms during these reactions. Cyanide and carbon monoxide trapping studies reveal that hydroxyurea oxidizes deoxyhemoglobin to methemoglobin and reduces methemoglobin to deoxyhemoglobin. Similar experiments reveal that iron nitrosyl hemoglobin formation specifically occurs during the reaction of hydroxyurea and methemoglobin. Experiments with hydroxyurea analogues indicate that nitric oxide transfer requires an unsubstituted acylhydroxylamine group and that the reactions of hydroxyurea and deoxy- and methemoglobin likely proceed by inner-sphere mechanisms. The formation of nitrate during the reaction of hydroxyurea and oxyhemoglobin and the lack of nitrous oxide production in these reactions suggest the intermediacy of nitric oxide as opposed to its redox form nitroxyl. A mechanistic model that includes a redox cycle between deoxyhemoglobin and methemoglobin has been forwarded to explain these results that define the reactivity of hydroxyurea and hemoglobin. These direct nitric oxide producing reactions of hydroxyurea and hemoglobin may contribute to the overall pathophysiological properties of this drug.