Glycogen synthase kinase-3 (GSK-3) is a master regulator of growth and death in cardiac myocytes. GSK-3 is inactivated by hypertrophic stimuli through phosphorylation-dependent and -independent mechanisms. Inactivation of GSK-3 removes the negative constraint of GSK-3 on hypertrophy, thereby stimulating cardiac hypertrophy. N-terminal phosphorylation of the GSK-3 isoforms GSK-3α and GSK-3β by upstream kinases (e.g., Akt) is a major mechanism of GSK-3 inhibition. Nonetheless, its role in mediating cardiac hypertrophy and failure remains to be established. Here we evaluated the role of Serine(S)21 and S9 phosphorylation of GSK-3α and GSK-3β in the regulation of cardiac hypertrophy and function during pressure overload (PO), using GSK-3α S21A knock-in (αKI) and GSK-3β S9A knock-in (βKI) mice. Although inhibition of S9 phosphorylation during PO in the βKI mice attenuated hypertrophy and heart failure (HF), inhibition of S21 phosphorylation in the αKI mice unexpectedly promoted hypertrophy and HF. Inhibition of S21 phosphorylation in GSK-3α, but not of S9 phosphorylation in GSK-3β, caused phosphorylation and down-regulation of G1-cyclins, due to preferential localization of GSK-3α in the nucleus, and suppressed E2F and markers of cell proliferation, including phosphorylated histone H3, under PO, thereby contributing to decreases in the total number of myocytes in the heart. Restoration of the E2F activity by injection of adenovirus harboring cyclin D1 with a nuclear localization signal attenuated HF under PO in the αKI mice. Collectively, our results reveal that whereas S9 phosphorylation of GSK-3β mediates pathological hypertrophy, S21 phosphorylation of GSK-3α plays a compensatory role during PO, in part by alleviating the negative constraint on the cell cycle machinery in cardiac myocytes.